Get Nrdly Free Trial Built with Nrdly

Rose’s Lemon Shortbread Recipe

Shortbread is not the sort of biscuit that inspires me. It’s not soft and chewy inside…

Shortbread is not the sort of biscuit that inspires me. It’s not soft and chewy inside. It’s not laced with half-melted chocolate. It’s not overflowing with nuts, toasted to magnificence. You don’t have the option to half-cook it, leaving glorious centres that are only one step removed from dough. The dough doesn’t even taste that good, and that’s just unforgivable. I mean, one of the joys of baking biscuits or cookies is the fact that you get to snarfle dough in the interests of quality control.

It’s that biscuit everyone’s nan makes when she Has Company, and it tends toward dry and crumbly, leaving you brushing crumbs surreptitiously off your Visiting clothes and onto the overstuffed sofa that was fashionable in the years before you were born. Its saving grace, I suppose, is that it’s always accompanied by tea, as all those crumbs need washing down. This is especially handy when the biscuit in question tastes of little more than butter grease and a whiff of slightly burned cat hair from that time Angus got his tail stuck in the oven door. You need something to take the taste away.

lemon shortbread recipe Mary Berry Beaufort Scales Toot Hansell

I mean, sure, it *looks* fine. I bet it tastes of pocket lint and sadness, though.

I mean, I know not all shortbread is created equal, and maybe your nan makes a perfectly acceptable biscuit, dry and crumbly and tasteless, but at least not cat-hair-flavoured. Then again – old ovens being what they are – there’s always the chance they’re overcooked to the point that you’re grateful Nan’s pug has the culinary discernment characteristic of his species.

I will qualify this by saying that one of my nana’s neighbours made shortbread that was basically famous, and as a wee small thing I was always excited when Mrs Bickerton had either popped by with some, or we were allowed to visit and have some at her house. But this may have just contributed to my dissatisfaction with shortbread in general, as nothing else has so far lived up to such exceptional standards.

However. While I have no particular affection for shortbread – or haven’t until recently, anyway – Rose, from the Beaufort Scales cozy mystery series, is well-known for her shortbread. That, and her rum truffles, but they’re more of a Christmas treat and are known to draw the attention of certain elderly dragons, as you may remember from A Toot Hansell Christmas Cracker.

lemon shortbread recipe Mary Berry Beaufort Scales Toot Hansell

And since the newest Beaufort mystery, Coming Up Roses (which is coming at the end of this month!), features rather a lot of Rose, I felt it was time to tackle my shortbread prejudices. And since we have a lemon tree here that insists on flinging lemons at us, I decided that lemon shortbread would be fun. And also, as has been previously established, following recipes is not something I’m great at, so …

I did not have high hopes. I thought the lemon might cheer things up a bit, and I chucked some vanilla and salt in, because what’s a recipe without vanilla and salt? And I figured that Dad likes shortbread, so he’d eat it even if no one else did.

Lovely people, I take back all the nasty things I have ever said about shortbread. I apologise for vilifying the glory that is freshly baked shortbread, and I promise to never, ever do it again.

Because this is exceptional. It’s delicate. It doesn’t crumble so much as melt. The lemon’s a little shout of sunshine. The semolina gives a lovely little crunch to contrast with all that meltiness. And it’s so ridiculously easy that, since Dad’s basically eaten the lot in two days (okay, yes, I helped), I think I may just make some more. I am a shortbread convert.

So here is Rose’s lemon shortbread recipe, based on Mary Berry’s basic recipe. Because you can’t get more English than a Mary Berry shortbread recipe.

lemon shortbread recipe Mary Berry Beaufort Scales Toot Hansell

Rose’s Lemon Shortbread

  • 225 g / 8 oz / 16 tbsp butter
  • 100 g / 1/2 cup sugar
  • grated zest of one lemon
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla
  • pinch salt
  • 225 g / 1 1/2 cups flour
  • 100 g / just under 2/3 cup semolina

Prepare a 30 x 23cm (9 x 12 inch) tin by greasing lightly – I laid a sheet of parchment paper across it to use as a sling to help get them out, but you probably don’t need to. If you do use it, trim it so it doesn’t crinkle in the corners.

Work butter, sugar, lemon zest and vanilla together until roughly mixed. You want the butter juuuust soft enough to work with. You’re not looking to cream it or anything – all you’re doing here is getting the zest and the vanilla all muddled in with the rest.

Mix salt, flour and semolina (I didn’t have any semolina, but I did have fairly fine cornmeal, which is basically the same thing. Same enough for Kim standards, anyway). Add to the butter mix and rub together with your fingertips until you get a breadcrumb-like texture, and it’s starting to stick together.

Knead it very lightly, just to get it mostly together in one big clump, then press it into your tin and level it off with the back of a spoon. Do the pretty little fork holes all over it (they don’t have to go in too deep), then pop the tin in the fridge and chill until firm.

Once firm, pre-heat your oven to 160C /320F (with no fan – drop down to 140C / 280 F with a fan oven). Bake for around 30 – 35 minutes, or until pale golden brown. I went for the lower end, and I love the just-baked texture, but for more firmness give it a wee bit longer.

As soon as your shortbread’s out, sprinkle it with a little sugar then cut into fingers while still in the tin. Give them a few minutes to cool and firm up, then transfer to a rack. (This is where I just slid them all out together on the parchment paper. It sounded like a faff to do them one by one…)

Cool, devour, repeat.

If you wanted to leave the lemon out, you certainly could. Or substitute for orange zest. You could also add some flaked almonds or other nuts for more texture, or change the zest for some coffee granules and chuck some chocolate chips in. The possibilities are endless! Or, at least, many and varied.

lemon shortbread recipe Mary Berry Beaufort Scales Toot Hansell


Lovely people, is there a biscuit/cookie that has always been a bit ‘meh’ to you? Has anything happened to change your mind? Let me know below!

And you can read the first chapter of Coming Up Roses here, should you fancy!

Until then – happy baking!

baking, Beaufort Scales, books, homemade, new releases, recipes, shortbread, Toot Hansell

  1. Kelvin Gosnell says:

    New Dragons at end of month. Counting the days! Loved the “Unicorns” by the way. How can you not love a solipsist donkey. Also, elsewhere, enchanted by the creatures which feed on fear in changing rooms. Echoes our daughters’ comments about H&M (specialist in skinny-bird clothes) changing rooms. They say they’re too dangerous to enter. Floor is deadly slippery from shed tears.

    1. Kim Watt says:

      Aw, I’m so glad you’re looking forward to the new Beaufort, and enjoying Gobs in the meantime! And, I mean, you just have to look at donkeys to know they’re pondering Great and Important things. Maybe. 😉

      I’m with your daughter on H&M. On most clothing shops, to be honest, although nothing will match the horror of one (I can’t remember which store it was now), which had COMMUNAL changing rooms. So one couldn’t even bemoan one’s lack of supermodel legs in private. This is why I think online shopping, for all its issues, is kind of wonderful…

  2. Beckett says:

    I don’t share your (prior) shortbread aversion, possibly due to the half of my lineage that bears Scottish genes, but more likely due to the fact that I was instructed in the process of making melt-in-your-mouth perfect shortbread (OMG! So perfect when topped by clotted cream and raspberry jam!) by a true, transplanted Scottish lady with whom I worked in the unlikely environment of a government entity in the city of Charleston, South Carolina. She made the clotted cream, too, and those of us who benefited from her largesse rose up and called her blessed!

    1. Kim Watt says:

      I am a disgrace to my Scottish heritage. My dad’s Scottish, and he always told me I must never let on to my nana that I put brown sugar on my porridge instead of salt. THE HORROR. Nana moved out to NZ when Dad was 13, and she always sounded as if she’d just arrived the day before. Such a beautiful accent! Yet somehow I never took to her shortbread, which is yet another count against me…

      However, it was also never offered to me accompanied by clotted cream and jam, and I have suspicions that might well have caused me to have a completely different opinion!


    Ooooh! Those sound divine 🙂 I must confess I love Shortbread. Mostly I think because I grew up eating my mothers recipe (which she made for holidays). It had been handed down through the years from her 4 times grandmother. If I figured all those generations correctly anyway, who was from Scotland. I’ve tried adding flavors but never thought about lemon. Can’t wait to try it!
    I also LOVE my cookies (biscuits) soft and chewy and slightly under baked. I think my favorite is Oatmeal with everything but the kitchen sink. Whatever is in the pantry. Dried fruits, nuts, chocolate chips, you name it! And I just can’t get excited about crispy cut out Christmas cookies with sprinkles which are my husband’s favorites. Not unless they are at least heavily frosted 😀
    I also can’t wait for the new Beaufort scales book!! My finger is poised over the Kindle itching to hit the “buy it now “ button 😉

    1. Kim Watt says:

      No! I’ve never understood the popularity of any biscuit that can be rolled thin and cut out. Every time I’ve had one it’s been dry, crumbly, and tasteless, and completely misses the point of a good biscuit/cookie. Although, some of those complaints I have also levelled at shortbread, so maybe I just haven’t had the right ones.

      Your oatmeal cookies sound SO good. I’ve never quite got the hang of oatmeal cookies – other than Anzacs (which are DELIGHTFUL), mine always seem to come up soggy and not-quite-right tasting. As if they’re not sure whether they’re a cake or a biscuit. It’s most disappointing, as I love oats and dried fruits and all those good things.

      And definitely try the lemon! It gives it such a lovely lift. I thought it really made them.

      I’m so happy you’re excited about the newest Beaufort! I am too – I can’t wait to share it with you!

  4. Vaunda Bonnett says:

    I make a decent shortbread, but borrowing a concept from Martha Stewart, I used tea as the flavoring. I’ve done matcha and Earl Grey versions, and as I just got an Earl Grey with rose petals, that might need to go in, too. It does limit the the one can drink with the shortbread to lighter flavored blacks like Darjeeling, though. I’ve already put lemon on the shopping list to make a batch for the reading of the nre book. An eat-along with Beaufort adventure!

    1. Kim Watt says:

      Ooh, an Earl Grey-flavoured shortbread sounds lovely! I never like it to drink, but I think that really floral/herbal fragrance would be lovely in baking. And with rose petals – I can’t imagine anything more appropriate!

      I also love the idea of an eat-long adventure. 😁

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *